Friday 1 March 2013

Which size of Filofax is best?

This is a frequent question with no single correct answer. Even if we put aside the choice of binder colour and model there are still fundamental choices to be made.

The largest size is the A4 Filofax. If you are planning to add your own content to your organiser this is the easiest size to accommodate you. At least in Europe, A4 paper is ubiquitous. It is almost certainly what emerges from your (European) printer when you click on the PRINT button.

Unlike all the other Filofax binders the A4 features standard rings and spacing. There are 4 rings and the configuration is exactly the same as a standard 4 ring binder you can buy in a stationery shop. That shop will also be able to sell you an inexpensive hole punch that is compatible with your Filofax.

The A4 binders are heavy and big. They work best when confined to a desk. Carrying one around with you everywhere is impractical, so these work best for people with sedentary jobs, or those who don’t get out much. For the rest of us, one of the smaller sizes is likely to be more convenient.

The A5 Filofax is one you see more frequently in business use than in social settings. The pages are half A4 size and in the same familiar proportion. A5 paper gives quite a generous space in most diary layouts, so take this into account. A week on 2 pages layout might be too cramped for you in Personal size, but ideal in A5. Overall this would save you considerable thickness in your diary section.

A5 is fairly easy to use if you want to print your own pages, but the 6 ring system means you’ll have to buy a special hole punch. A5s can be a little heavy, too. This size is not one you can practically carry everywhere in your hand, but kept in a bag or briefcase it is ideal.

If you are going to be writing more than just the occasional note this is a far more practical choice than the smaller sizes. Writing pages of meeting notes in the Personal size is much harder work than in the A5.

The next size down is the Personal Filofax. This was the only size at one time. If you owned a Filofax organiser it was one of these. Personal pages are a few millimetres wider than a credit card and about the height of three credit cards.

If you’re going to go with Personal size you have more of a ring size choice than with other sizes. The biggest rings in Personal size are 30mm. You can find these on the Cuban Zip, for example, and they will accommodate more pages than most A5s, albeit smaller ones. For me, the Personal size is the one you carry around in your hand. If you want to carry one around in your inside jacket pocket you can choose from the Slimline range and enjoy rings as small as 11mm, which are not going to be suitable for a page per day diary. But these binders are barely bigger than a full-length wallet, so are discreet and convenient if you always wear a jacket that will accommodate one. In between is the Compact, with medium-sized rings. Not as thick as a regular Personal, but accommodating more pages than the Slimline, these are fairly new. I think they will prove popular.

All Personals use a 6 ring layout so you’ll need a special hole punch if you make your own pages. Sadly, the spacings are not the same as in the A5, so it will need a second punch if you have both sizes. Another issue is that if you want to make your own pages you’ll find it hard to get paper in the right size except from Filofax, so you’ll probably want to print onto bigger, less expensive paper like A4 which you’ll then have to chop down.

The next size down is the Pocket Filofax, which is something of a misnomer – unless you have very commodious pockets. The page size is close to that in a Moleskine pocket notebook. The attraction of this size is its lightness and greater portability. Most of them can carry a good number of pages. Most are designed to double-up as a wallet as well. Six rings again, but with a different spacing once more.

Finally, we come to the Mini Filofax. I’m sure that the Mini is ideal for some people, but they are not people I know. All Filofax binders are wider and taller than the pages they contain, of course. For instance, Personal binders are about the same size as an A5 page. This extra size is for the rings, the pen loops and so on. In requiring the binder to be so small – and for those for whom this has any meaning we’re talking audio cassette-sized here – the page size has to be titchy to the point of unusability. There is only room enough for five rings and once you have punched the holes there is not much paper left. It would make a great stamp album if you are happy for each page only to bear a single stamp.

So there we are. Lots of choice. How do you decide which is right for you?

I think it comes down to the sort of life you live. If you do all your planning sitting at a desk, you will appreciate the space and convenience of the A4. If you want to take your planner home at weekends you’ll probably be glad you chose an A5. If you’re going to be using it more than occasionally on the go or in a social environment, Personal or Pocket might be your best bet for their easy portability. You need the right compromise between having paper big enough to organise your life on and a binder that is small enough and light enough to carry around everywhere with you.

On the other hand, if you have tiny pockets, minuscule writing or a very small stamp collection there’s a Mini with your name on it.


Raine said...

"I’m sure that the Mini is ideal for some people, but they are not people I know." You cracked me up on that one! I LOVE my minis (I have two), they are perfect as wallets and to carry shopping lists.

For all the rest (A5, personal, pocket) I keep exchanging between all them (currently on a personal) and always miss some feature of the size I just left behind :p

JohnofJenkins said...

I have tried a Mini and it was not a success. I carry my Personal around with me and I have a Cuban A5 on my desk, but the personal is my Filofax of choice.

Alan Marshall said...

Ray: The Pocket in a slimline (11MM rings) slips very nicely in a pocket and makes a great capture device. said...

If only it were that simple! I can't decide between the personal and the A5. I want more writing room but a smaller book. It's kind of like Goldilocks and the Three Bears. The Personal is too small. The A5 is too big. But where's the one that is just right???

Unknown said...

I got hooked after getting my pocket chameleon, which is also my wallet after slimming down a lot of what i keep in it; for example, I punched a hole in my numerous store cards, put them on a key ring and attach them to the inside of my bag.

Anywho, now that I need one for work I have gone for A5. It's so roomy in comparison, but I think A4 is just too big for me especially as I will take it home. Plus, thanks to your day planner template even on the busiest of days I can fit all the essential info in there.

So, my "pocket" one works best for personal things (trips, health appointments, yoga class, etc) even if I don't have any pockets big enough, and my A5 will take care of business, literally.

Unknown said...

I realise this is an old thread but I just wanted to say the the hole punch for the Personal (and Slimline and Compact) organisers can be used for the A5 as well if you are careful. All designs have rings in two blocks of three. The spaces between the blocks is wider for A5, but the spaces between the three rings in each set are the same. So for A5 you will need to punch one set of 3 with a Personal punch, then flip the paper over and punch the other 3. It takes a bit of trial and error on a spare piece of paper, but then you can make a mark on the punch indicating where the leading edge (top or bottom) of the paper needs to sit before you punch.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...